Digital Business After 40

Words that sell

How to Write a Call to Action That Feels Honest (12 Examples You Can Copy)

Your button words matter. Learn how to write a call to action after 40, with 12 honest examples you can copy and a quick 15-minute checklist. No hype.

Tina Alexander, founder of Digital Business After 40 By Tina Alexander

How to Write a Call to Action That Feels Honest (12 Examples You Can Copy)

You spend a whole evening on your product page. Six hundred honest words about what you made, who it’s for and why you made it. You read it out loud. It sounds like you.

Then you get to the button and type “Submit.”

I’ve done my own version of that. On social, my call to action was always “link in bio.” People clicked. They landed on my Beacons page, and the button said “Buy Now” or “Get It Free,” the same words everyone uses. I had no idea that tiny button had a job of its own.

The day my first sales came in, I kept refreshing that Beacons page all day. One sale, then another, then about four that first time. Real people had read what I made and decided it was for them. The button was the last thing they read before they said yes.

So here’s the short answer. A good call to action tells the reader exactly what they get when they click, in their words, with one calm line underneath about what happens next. No pressure. No shouting. Just a clear next step.

This guide shows you how, with 12 calls to action you can copy.

Key Takeaways

  • Your button should say what the reader gets, not what you want them to do.
  • “Learn more,” “Submit” and “Click here” are vague. Swap them for specifics.
  • The line under the button calms the last-second worry: what happens next, what it costs, how they get it.
  • One page, one main ask. More buttons usually mean fewer clicks.
  • “Link in bio” works best when you say what’s waiting in the bio.

Why Do “Learn More” and “Submit” Let You Down?

Because they make the reader do the guessing.

Nielsen Norman Group, a research firm that studies how people use websites, wrote a whole piece on this called “Learn More” Links: You Can Do Better. Their point is simple. A label like “Learn more” doesn’t tell people where they’re going, so they can’t predict what happens when they tap it. It’s also harder to use with a screen reader, because a page full of “Learn more” links all sound the same.

“Submit” has the same problem, plus one more. It’s a word from forms and paperwork. Nobody gets excited to submit anything.

Your reader is deciding whether to trust you. Every vague word makes that decision a little harder.

What Does a Good Call to Action Actually Do?

It finishes the sentence “I want to…” in the reader’s voice.

Read your button and put “I want to” in front of it:

  • “I want to… submit.” Nobody says that.
  • “I want to… learn more.” About what?
  • “I want to… get the 12 prompts.” Yes. That’s a real thing a real person wants.

A good call to action has two parts:

  1. An action word. Get, send, start, join, show, save, read.
  2. The thing they get. The checklist. The prompts. My copy. The first chapter.

That’s it. Short is fine. “Get the 12 prompts” is four words and does more work than “Click here to learn more about this amazing offer.”

Matching the reader matters too. HubSpot looked at more than 330,000 calls to action and found that personalized calls to action did 202% better than basic ones. That study was about buttons that change for each visitor. You don’t need fancy software to borrow the lesson, though. Write your button for the one person you made your product for, and use the words they’d use.

If the words above your button are still vague, fix those first. My guide on writing a product description that sells walks you through it, and the free Words That Sell pack has 25 vague phrases with what to say instead.

What Goes in the Line Under the Button?

This is the part almost everyone skips, and it does a lot of quiet work.

Right before someone clicks, a little worry pops up. Will I get a hundred emails? Is this a subscription? What if I can’t find the download? The line under your button answers that worry before it turns into “maybe later.”

Pick the one that fits:

  • What happens next. “You’ll get it by email in about a minute.”
  • What it costs. “$7, one-time. No subscription.”
  • What they don’t have to do. “No credit card. Nothing to fill in first.”
  • How long it takes. “Five questions. Takes two minutes.”
  • Your policy, plainly. If digital downloads are final sale, say so: “Digital downloads are final sale, so peek at the preview first.”

That last one surprises people. Saying “final sale” out loud feels risky. It isn’t. Being plain about it builds trust, and the buyers who come through are the ones who already know what they’re getting. If you want the bigger picture on what happens after the click, my guide to delivering a digital product covers it.

12 Calls to Action You Can Copy

Change the details to fit your product. Keep the shape.

For a free download

  1. Send me the checklist Free. It lands in your inbox in about a minute.
  2. Get the free pack Opens on your phone. Nothing to fill in first.
  3. Show me the sample pages A quick preview. No email needed.

For a paid product

  1. Get the 12 prompts $7, one-time. Instant download.
  2. Get my copy for $9 Lifetime access. Digital downloads are final sale.
  3. Start with the template You’ll get the link right after checkout.

For a community or a live call

  1. Join the free community Free to join. Leave anytime.
  2. Save my seat Free live call. The replay goes to everyone who signs up.
  3. Ask me a question I read and answer every message myself.

For a reader who isn’t ready yet

  1. Read the first chapter free No sign-up. Just scroll.
  2. Take the 2-minute quiz Five questions. Your answer shows up right away.
  3. Compare the three bundles See what’s in each one before you pick.

Notice what’s missing from all twelve. No “now.” No “hurry.” No “only 3 left.” Nothing that would make you wince if a friend read it out loud.

“Link in bio” is a call to action too, and it’s usually the first one your reader sees. The button on your page is the second.

On its own, “link in bio” has the same problem as “Learn more.” It doesn’t say what’s there. Give it one more line:

  • Instead of “Link in bio,” try “The free checklist is the first link in my bio.”
  • Instead of “Check my bio,” try “Grab the 12 prompts. They’re at the top of my bio.”

Then make sure the button on the page they land on matches. If your post promised a free checklist, the button should say “Send me the checklist,” not “Submit.” When the words match from post to page, people feel like they’re in the right place.

How Many Buttons Should One Page Have?

One main ask per page.

You can repeat the same button lower down on a long page, so people don’t have to scroll back up. That’s still one ask. What hurts is five different buttons asking for five different things: buy this, join that, follow me, read this, take the quiz. The reader has to choose, and choosing is work. Often they choose nothing.

If you’re building the whole page, my guide on writing a simple sales page shows where the button goes and what comes right before it. And if you haven’t set up the place your page lives yet, start with setting up an online storefront.

Which Words Should You Leave Off Your Buttons?

Leave off anything you’d be embarrassed to say face to face.

  • Fake urgency. “Hurry!” “Last chance!” on a product that will be there next week.
  • Fake scarcity. “Only 5 left” on a digital file anyone can download.
  • Guilt. “No thanks, I don’t want to grow my business.” You’ve seen those. Don’t be that.
  • Hype words. Ultimate. Secret. Skyrocket. Explode.
  • Income promises. Never put a dollar amount someone will “make” on a button or anywhere near it.

If something is truly limited, like a live call with a real date, say the real date. That’s not pressure. That’s information.

Still stuck on the words around your button? The Words That Sell pack has a 10-minute checklist and copy-and-paste AI prompts that help you draft it and then cut the hype.

Fix Every Button on Your Page in 15 Minutes

Set a timer. Grab your Diet Coke, coffee or whatever keeps you going.

  1. Find every button and link (3 minutes). Your product page, your link-in-bio page, the end of your emails. Write each one down.
  2. Do the “I want to” test (3 minutes). Put “I want to” in front of each button. Cross out any that sound odd.
  3. Rewrite the crossed-out ones (4 minutes). Action word plus the thing they get. Use the 12 examples above.
  4. Add one line under each main button (3 minutes). What happens next, what it costs or what they don’t have to do.
  5. Match your “link in bio” (2 minutes). Update your social bio and your latest post so they say what’s waiting there.

Then read the whole page out loud, top to bottom, one time. If the button sounds like the same person who wrote everything above it, you’re done.

Want the bigger picture behind starting late? The Late Starters Advantage is my free guide for people building online after 40. It covers mindset, naming your brand, a 30-day what-to-post calendar, 10 AI prompts, and setting up a simple storefront. Get The Late Starters Advantage

Questions people ask about this

What is a call to action?

A call to action is the words that ask your reader to take the next step. It’s usually a button or a link, like “Get the checklist” or “Join the free community.” On social media, “link in bio” is a call to action too.

How long should a call to action be?

Usually two to five words on the button itself. Put the extra details in one short line underneath, like the price or what happens next. Short is fine as long as it’s specific.

Is “Buy Now” a bad call to action?

It isn’t bad, it’s just generic. It tells people to buy but not what they get. “Get my copy for $9” or “Get the 12 prompts” says the same thing and answers the reader’s question at the same time.

Should I mention my refund policy near the button?

Yes, in one plain line. If your digital downloads are final sale, say so and point people to a preview or sample so they can check first. Being upfront builds more trust than hoping nobody asks.

Can AI help me write my calls to action?

Yes. Copy this prompt into Claude or ChatGPT:

I sell a digital product called [product name] for [price]. It’s for [who it’s for] who are stuck on [their problem]. Write 10 button labels of 2 to 5 words that say exactly what the buyer gets. Under each one, write one calm sentence about what happens after they click. No urgency, no hype words, no income claims. Write it the way a friend would say it.

Then read the list out loud and keep the one that sounds most like you.

You Already Know How to Ask

Before I ever built anything online, I was an office manager. A big part of that job was asking people for things, all day long. Sign here. I need this back by Thursday. Can you call the vendor before noon?

None of that was pushy. It was clear. People knew exactly what I needed, when, and why. So they did it.

That’s all a call to action is. A clear, kind ask from someone who knows what she’s offering.

You’ve been doing this your whole life. Nobody had to teach you how to ask. The internet just made you forget you knew.