Building a free community
Skool or Facebook Group? Where to Host a Free Community After 40
Trying to choose between Skool and a Facebook group for your free community? Here is what each really costs, how I chose, and what settles it fastest.
You have decided to start a community. Good. Then you open Google to pick a platform, and three hours later you have twelve tabs open and zero members.
I know that spot. So let me save you the tabs.
Here is the short answer. Host your free community where your people already spend their day, unless you plan to teach step by step, in which case a platform with a classroom, like Skool, is worth a small monthly fee. If you cannot decide, start with email or a small group chat. You can always move later.
Key Takeaways
- The platform matters less than you think. Your people join because of you, not the software.
- A Facebook group is free and familiar, but noisy, and you do not own the list.
- Skool is calm and organized, but it costs the owner a monthly fee and you bring every member yourself.
- Email is the one thing you fully own. Collect emails from day one, wherever you host.
- Three questions settle it in ten minutes.
The platform matters less than you think, except in two ways
Your first members will not join because of the software. They will join because of you. Your story, your patience, the fact that you also started this after 40 and still remember what it felt like to not know what a “post” was.
So the platform is not the big decision. But it does matter in two ways.
First, where your people already spend their day. If they have to download a new app and make a new password, some of them will not. That is not a tech problem. That is a habit problem.
Second, what you own when it grows. Some platforms let you see your members, email them, and organize your teaching. Some keep all of that behind their own walls.
Hold those two things in mind and the rest gets simple. If you want the full picture of starting from zero, read my guide on how to build an online community after 40.
The only three places worth considering right now
There are dozens of community tools. You only need to think about three.
- A Facebook group. Free. Your people are probably already on Facebook.
- Skool. A paid platform built just for communities and courses.
- An email list or a WhatsApp group. The smallest possible start.
Everything else is a version of these with more buttons.
Facebook group: what it gets right, what it quietly costs you
What it gets right:
- It costs nothing.
- Your people are already there. Pew Research’s 2025 survey found 71% of U.S. adults use Facebook, and it is one of only two platforms a majority of every age group uses.
- No new login, no new app, no learning curve for your members.
That last one is big. You remove the biggest reason people do not show up.
What it quietly costs you:
- The feed is noisy. Your post sits between a cousin’s vacation photos and an ad for shoes. Facebook decides who sees it.
- You do not own the list. You cannot email your members. If you lose access to the group, those people are gone.
- Teaching is clumsy. Organizing lessons so a new member can follow them step by step takes real work.
A Facebook group is a great front porch. It is a harder place to build the house.
Skool: why I pay for it, and when you should not
My community, Digital Business After 40, lives on Skool. Here is the honest version of why.
I posted on social media on and off for about two years. Not much happened. Things only started to move once I had my own community and began showing up in other people’s communities too. A lot of those were on Skool. I was already there every day, learning, commenting, making friends. So when I built my own, I built it in the room I was already standing in.
What Skool gives you:
- A calm space. No ads, no cousins, no shoes. Just your people.
- A classroom. Your lessons sit in order, so a new member knows exactly where to start.
- Members who came on purpose. Someone who joins a Skool community chose to be there.
What it costs you:
- Money. Skool charges the community owner a monthly fee. The entry Hobby plan runs $9 a month at the time of writing, so check their current pricing page before you sign up. Members still join your free community at no cost.
- A new habit for your members. Some people will join, then forget to come back. You have to give them a reason.
- Nobody is there yet. On Facebook, people are already scrolling. On Skool, you bring every single person yourself.
When I would tell you not to use Skool:
If you have not posted anything anywhere yet, and you do not know who your people are, wait. Start smaller. Skool is a wonderful home. It is not a way to find your people.
If you do choose Skool, my step-by-step guide on how to start a free Skool community walks you through the first afternoon and the first five members.
What about just using email or WhatsApp?
These count. Seriously.
Email is the one thing you fully own. If every platform disappeared tomorrow, your email list would still be yours. A weekly note to 20 people is a community. Here is how to start an email list after 40 if that is your first step.
WhatsApp works well for small, close groups. Many of us already use it with family. It gets chaotic past a few dozen members, and nothing is organized, but for a first circle of 10 people it is hard to beat.
If you are frozen on the platform question, start here. You can always move later.
Three questions that decide it in ten minutes
Grab a notebook. Answer these honestly.
1. Where do my people already show up every day? Not where you wish they were. Where they actually are. If the answer is Facebook, that matters a lot.
2. Am I teaching, or mostly talking? If you plan to teach step by step, you want a classroom. That points to Skool. If it is mostly support and conversation, a Facebook group or WhatsApp is fine.
3. Can I spend a small monthly fee without stressing about it? If yes, Skool is an option. If not, start free. A free community you actually run beats a paid one you keep putting off.
Two answers pointing the same way? That is your platform. Done. Close the tabs.
How to move later without losing the people you have
This is the part nobody tells you. Your first choice is not forever.
- Collect emails from day one. On any platform, offer something simple in exchange for an email. That list moves with you.
- Tell people early. “We might move someday, and I will bring you with me.” No surprise, no betrayal.
- Move with a reason. “We are moving so the lessons are easier to find” works. “I read a review” does not.
- Keep the old space open for a few weeks. Post a friendly pointer to the new home and let people walk over at their own pace.
The people who love being there will follow you. That is the whole point of a community.
Questions people ask about this
Is Skool better than a Facebook group?
Not automatically. Skool is calmer and better for teaching, and a Facebook group is free and already part of your members’ day. The better one is the one your people will actually open. If you teach step by step and can pay a small monthly fee, Skool is worth a look.
Can I run a free community without paying for software?
Yes. A Facebook group, an email list, or a WhatsApp group all cost nothing to start. Many communities begin that way and move once they need a classroom or a calmer space.
Are Facebook groups dead?
No. Facebook is still where a large share of adults over 40 spend part of every day. The trade-off is noise and ownership, not empty rooms.
Can I move my community later?
Yes. Collect emails from the start, tell members early that a move might happen, and give them a clear reason when it does. The people who value the community will come with you.
Pick the room your people will walk into
You do not need the trendy platform. You need the room your people will actually walk into.
After 40, you already know where your people spend their mornings. That is not a small thing. It is the shortcut every platform review misses.
Pick one. Post your first welcome. Keep showing up.
You are not too old. You are not too late.
Want to see how a free Skool community works from the inside? Come join mine, Digital Business After 40. It is free, it is full of people over 40 building their first online business, and nobody will make you feel behind.